Recommended Draft Policy ARIN-2021-8
Deprecation of the ‘Autonomous System Originations’ Field
Shepherds: Alicia Trotman, Anita Nikolich
Current Text (26 October 2022)
AC Assessment of Conformance with the Principles of Internet Number Resource Policy:
Based on community feedback and AC discussion we motion to move ARIN-2021-8: Deprecation of the ‘Autonomous System Originations’ Field to Recommended Draft, with the following change to Language: The removal of ‘OriginAs’ fields from December 31st 2024 to 24 months after board adoption.
In the last two decades, ARIN has developed multiple services which provide mechanisms for Internet Number Resource holders to publish information about their routing intentions.
The optional ‘OriginAS’ field was invented before RPKI existed in practice. At that time, ARIN’s Internet Routing Registry (IRR) followed a weak authorization model compared to available and in use today such as RPKI. The ‘OriginAS’ data was an improvement compared the other mechanisms that were available at that time.
However, there are issues with the consumption of the data in the OriginAS field:
Consuming the ‘OriginAS’ field in a high-scale automated pipeline is challenging. The consumer needs to enter into a ‘Bulk Whois Data’ agreement with ARIN, download a multiple-gigabytes XML file (which is only generated once a day), parse this XML file, and then extract the OriginAS field. Querying objects one-by-one via the HTTPS interface does not scale well.
- Remove Section 3.5 “Autonomous System Originations” of the NRPM in its entirety.
- Remove the ‘OriginAS’ field from the database
Timetable for Implementation:
- Removal of section 3.5: Immediate after ARIN Board adoption.
- Removal of the ‘OriginAS’ field from the database: 24 months after ARIN Board adoption.
Policy Term: Permanent
Staff and Legal Review (5 October 2022)
ARIN-2021-8 would remove the entirety of ARIN policy surrounding Autonomous System Originations, including guidelines for ARIN’s origin AS data collection and publication.
As stated in previous staff and legal reviews, the problem statement identifies issues with efficient access to OriginAS data, but the policy statement proposes elimination of the data altogether, rather than proposing potential solutions to the identified shortcomings. Staff recommends careful consideration of impacted customers and their ability to find alternatives to information contained in the OriginAS field within the stated implementation timeframe.
Staff understands this Draft Policy to have two implementation milestones; one for removal of the policy language, and one for removal of the field and all data contained in that field from ARIN databases. Staff recommends the second be adjusted to two years from adoption rather than a fixed date that may need to adjust as the Draft Policy moves through the PDP.
Implementable as Written?: Yes
Impact on ARIN Registry Operations and Services:
Involves removal of fields and database objects of significant scope.
No material legal issue.
Implementation Timeframe Estimate:
Three months for removal of the policy language. Second timeframe will be followed according to the text, if adopted, but not within fewer than nine months from adoption.
- Customer education and outreach with appropriate sunsetting lead times
- Staff training
- Updates to public documentation
- Updates to internal procedures and guidelines
Proposal/Draft Policy Text Assessed: 13 September 2022
History and Earlier Versions
|7 July 2021
|18 November 2021
|16 December 2021
|13 September 2022
|26 October 2022
|19 April 2023
|Advanced to Board of Trustees
|23 May 2023
|18 July 2023